I interrupt Chookooloonks for the following editorial:
Recently, several people have asked me my opinion about this story. Well, not so much "asked my opinion," as much as said something closer to: "DEAR GOD, DID YOU HEAR THAT STORY ABOUT A JUDGE WHO RIPPED THIS COUPLE'S CHILD FROM THEIR VERY ARMS, AND RETURNED THE CHILD TO THE BIRTHMOTHER? AREN'T YOU PETRIFIED?!?!? YOU COULD LOSE ALEX FOREVER!!!! And then they search my face for a reaction with their wide, panic-striken eyes.
For those of you who haven't read the story, it's a bit confusing. But basically, the facts appear to be as follows:
- BioMom gets pregnant.
- BioMom chooses Adoptive Parents to raise Kid.
- Adoptive Parents are present for Kid's birth, and take Kid home after 2 days.
- BioMom visits Adoptive Parents and Kid regularly.
- Right before the adoption is final (<-- Note: VERY important fact), BioDad pops up, contests the adoption and files claim for custody of Kid.
- The court finds that BioDad has the right to contest the adoption, and are about to award BioDad custody of Kid.
- Seeing BioDad about to get custody, BioMom goes "oh HELL, no," and files her OWN claim for custody of Kid.
- Hijinx ensue.
- Three-and-a-half years later, court awards BioMom custody of Kid.
Okay, I certainly see why this story is disturbing. I mean, here we have these poor adoptive parents who have bonded with this child for 3-1/2 years, only to be told that they're actually not mom & dad. I can't imagine their anguish.
That said, this story doesn't worry me about our adoption situation in the least. There are several reasons for this:
1) That was Florida, this is Texas. Adoption laws vary from state-to-state; and
2) At the time that BioDad contested the adoption, his rights were obviously not yet terminated. Alex's biodad's parental rights were terminated within 8 weeks of her birth; and finally
3) The adoption wasn't final. This is very important. Most people who relate this story to me seem to be under the impression that the judge reversed an adoption order -- this was not the case. The court simply refused to grant the adoption.
In our case, the adoption of Alex is oh-so-very final. What the Fort Bend County Court has decreed, let no man put asunder.
What does worry me about this story, however, is its effect on prospective adoptive parents. I worry that couples who may be considering adoption as their way to grow their family may be turned off by this story, believing that all (or a significant percentage of) adoptions fail, or are reversed, or are somehow "unofficial." I worry that waiting children may have to wait longer, because the press has chosen to sensationalize this particular story, making it appear to be the rule, rather than the exception. I worry that people will become anti- open adoptions, believing that all birthmothers are "stalkers" or "unable to let go."
So, as my public service announcement for today, let me state, unequivocally, to anyone contemplating adoption, the following:
1). The reason that you read about failed adoptions in the press is because failure sells. You don't hear about the successful, healthy adoptions because, let's face it, "successful" and "healthy" often aren't sexy. The truth is that a stunning majority of adoptions end happily, with well-adjusted adoptive parents parenting well-adjusted adopted kids.
2). That said, when entering into an adoptive relationship, remember that nothing can replace a good, knowledgeable adoption agency and/or attorney specializing in adoption. Adoption is tricky. Do NOT go this alone.
3) While all birthmothers certainly experience feelings of loss, they are NOT all "stalkers" or "unable to let go." With Alex's birthmother, I have never, EVER felt like she would stalk us, or contest the adoption, or do anything which threatened Alex or our relationship with Alex. And, remember, I say this in light of my January 16th post. Again, stories of stalker birthmoms sell. They are the exception, NOT the rule.
Don't get me wrong: adoption isn't easy. But it's not the nightmare the press likes to portray. And frankly, as happy as Marcus' life and my life have generally always been, adoption is the best thing that ever happened to us.
Period.
I now return you to your regularly scheduled Chookooloonks.